If you were destitute, would you become a beggar or a thief?
Reading
Sahalie's recent post about her man S's frustrating job at a call center got me to thinking about this question. It also got me to thinking about life, work, and life's-work.
It seems that S got frustrated, quit the job, and then got depressed about the state of things. A few doors were broken. Soothing words followed, calmness ensued. No lasting damage that a locksmith can't fix and nothing we all haven't been through in our own way.
S, whom I do not know except vicariously, gets high marks for having the dignity to walk away from a demeaning job. I've done call center work, as have many who read this blog, and the combination of low pay, quota pressure, and mechanization make it among the least rewarding and most difficult jobs I've ever worked. That is not to say that it isn't a blessing or a perfect job for some (to each his/her own) -- but it was a grind for me.
I quit one call center job after 4 days, scared shitless by watching workers stare woodenly at their screens for 2 hours until a break bell rang. They all jumped up, punched the clock, grabbed a deck of cards, rushed downstairs, played 10 minutes of cards, the bell rang again, they punched back in, and were staring woodenly at their computers 15 minutes later. Meanwhile, I sat at my desk and -- on break (mind you) -- clicked open Windows' Free Cell.
A nervous, incredulous hush filled the room.
"Wha...what are you doing?" a co-worker of mine finally had the wherewithal to stammer.
"Playing Free Cell. See, its break-time..." I started to explain.
The co-worker blanched and looked around the room with a wild look in his eyes.
"You can't *do* that," he said quickly and with a hushed voice, "they're...*watching*."
Then he went back to whatever he was doing and did his best to appear that he did not know me, had not spoken to me and, come to think of it had never even *seen* me.
That day I packed up my things and said hasta la vista to work at the hideously misnomered "fulfillment center".
The next time I worked in such a place was to do web research. I was given a computer and some rediculously vague assignment by someone who had no idea who or why I was there. They assured me that all I had to do all day was browse the web and look for whatever I was supposed to be looking for. (I'm not trying to be vague here: the assignment was really that general) Regardless of the pointlessness of the position, I was told very directly that some yahoo with a corner office spent his day spying on workers to make sure they weren't goofing off.
8 hours later I blew that joint for good.
My wife tells a story about working a crappy temp job for 3 hours then, at lunchtime, walking away and never returning. She never mentioned it to the boss, either, and the temp agency sputtered and raged and claimed she would "never work in this town again!"
It was a lie and now she laughs about the whole experience.
My father-in-law tells a story about scoring a big job with a repair company as a young man. He took apart a cash register for a customer, realized he had no clue how it went back together, and, without comment or preamble, simply left the parts on the boss's desk and walked out.
Last week, my friend B.C. got canned from his engineering job. The boss decided to pull rank on him and force him to choose vacation (which was owed him and which he was using to go home for Christmas) or work. Whenever a boss says "choose between me or your family/life/self-respect/dignity" it is time to get a new boss.
B.C. is bummed about it, I'm sure, but in 5 years from now he'll look back, laugh about what an S.O.B. his boss was, and know that he stood up for himself when it counted.
There are enough times in life when it is wisest not to resist. We all need work and money, and should be grateful that we have access to it in this country. Resisting is especially pointless when it is merely a question of vanity or ego -- pride is, not coincidentally, one of the deadly sins.
Some people would bitch that privelaged folk (like myself and many other middle classers) feel like we're better than people who work shit jobs for low pay and no respect. Its not that at all. Its just that when you have options -- whoever you are and in whatever context you have them -- you owe it to yourself to at least *fight* for self-respect, better working conditions, and the like. If you lose, at least you didn't just take what was coming and shuffle off to that great ticking time clock in the sky.
The beggar waits in the well-lit corner, holding the cup, secretly resenting passersby in whose pockets and upon whose benificience salvation lies. There is no dignity in begging, but the beggar is merely a nuisance (and not a threat) to others.
The thief waits in the dark corner, holding the sap, not resenting passersby because s/he, at least, has a measure of control over the situation. The thief is wicked and despised, but does not shrink from the mirror. If ever there is payback, the Thief will not divulge bitter coin.
I guess I have revealed my own bias here. Given the choice, I select the latter. I keep the trappings of a highwayman in my closet, just in case.