One of the things that has always bugged me about faith is that it is supposed to be something beyond rationality, beyond reason. You just *feel* it and then act forevermore like whatever you feel is unquestionably correct. The problem is, people feel all sorts of things, and emotions aren't necessarily tanamount to truth. Aside from the fact that emotions change (which they do) and conflict (which they also do), emotions are only to be trusted in the long term when they've been examined against the widest possible body of evidence. There's no sense in quitting the examination once you *feel* you've discovered the truth. Why? Because you'll change. Why? Because the world will seem different ten years from now. Why? Because we're all just floundering around on a mote of dust talking ourselves silly until we think we've arrived at the truth. Our feelings don't mean shit. People *feel* that Vishnu is watching, George Bush "feels strongly" that attacking Iraq will preserve peace, somebody *feels* that their dead husband doesn't want them to eat wheat germ. Whatever. In the old days, people suspected the sun was a glowing testicle pulled across the sky by giant invisible oxen. They had faith that tossing virgins into volcanos kept Pele happy. Aztecs slew thousands in the name of Quetzecoatl. But the point is not to drum up the tired old litany of religious abuses: people have done great things in the name of religion, too. The problem I have is that wishing something to be -- even wishing it so badly or ignoring alternatives so consciously -- doesn't change the reality. Do I understand faith? Very much so. I have equal faith that a giant rubberized daffodil calls the shots than some haloed twelve armed virgin on a golden camel. I've spent hours discussing faith with my old man (a minister). I've felt the warmth and love of religious good feeling, the beauty of community united even if the fundamental premise was a bit wonky. Religion provides meaning, and people with a sense of purpose seem to feel better about things. Still, it doesn't make religious beliefs any truer. My old man does great work with people -- he's one of the best people people I've ever met. He couldn't do what he does without some sort of larger framework to operate in -- people just wouldn't go for it if he prayed to a rubberized daffodil.
I think one of the biggest assumptions that people with faith make is to assume that the rest of the world needs some higher order of being to judge their lives by, to gain comfort from, to provide purpose. I have a supreme faith in the quality of human beings and the beauty of life. That beauty is only increased with the knowledge that there is no larger meaning to it, that it is so ephemeral, so transitory. I am amazed at how relavent the existentialist philosophers continue to be. I thought for awhile there that they would just be another intellectual fad acquired and tossed aside during my teen years. They have proven to be more resiliant than I thought. Still, I fight against them: I don't find the universe bleak and cold and humorless for all of its lack of god or higher importance. I find it funny that we walk around all puffed up and sure of ourselves, screaming platitudes into the void, fucking each other silly, making up riddles and games and obstacles, defining everything, catagorizing the universe as if we were masters of it. I repeat: we ain't shit, we don't know shit. No need for me to get shrill about it, though. People would be infernally dull if they all believed the same thing and God knows maybe I'll change my mind someday...
Merry Daffodil Day, all.
:)
I think one of the biggest assumptions that people with faith make is to assume that the rest of the world needs some higher order of being to judge their lives by, to gain comfort from, to provide purpose. I have a supreme faith in the quality of human beings and the beauty of life. That beauty is only increased with the knowledge that there is no larger meaning to it, that it is so ephemeral, so transitory. I am amazed at how relavent the existentialist philosophers continue to be. I thought for awhile there that they would just be another intellectual fad acquired and tossed aside during my teen years. They have proven to be more resiliant than I thought. Still, I fight against them: I don't find the universe bleak and cold and humorless for all of its lack of god or higher importance. I find it funny that we walk around all puffed up and sure of ourselves, screaming platitudes into the void, fucking each other silly, making up riddles and games and obstacles, defining everything, catagorizing the universe as if we were masters of it. I repeat: we ain't shit, we don't know shit. No need for me to get shrill about it, though. People would be infernally dull if they all believed the same thing and God knows maybe I'll change my mind someday...
Merry Daffodil Day, all.
:)